Rutherford County Market Report

What Does It Mean When Sellers Outnumber Buyers in the Nashville Area?

By John Turner Turner Victory Team October 21, 2026
Quick Answer

When sellers outnumber buyers, there are more homes for sale than people ready to buy them. Redfin reports that sellers outnumbered buyers by 62.6% across the country in September 2026, the widest gap in its records, which go back to 2013. In the Nashville metro the gap was about 152%, second in the nation. For buyers, that means more choices and more room to negotiate. For sellers, it means price and presentation matter more than ever.

Turner Victory Team data for the week ending October 17, 2026 shows Rutherford County with 1,730 homes for sale, 3.65 months of supply and a Market Health Score of 35, which points to a buyer’s market.

62.6% More Sellers Than Buyers, U.S.
152.3% More Sellers Than Buyers, Nashville Metro
41 of 50 Large Metros Are Buyer’s Markets
35 Turner Victory Team Market Health Score

If you have seen the headline that sellers outnumber buyers, you may be wondering what it means for your move. The short version is that buyers have more power than they have had in years. The longer version depends on whether you are buying or selling, and that is what this article walks through.

A new Redfin report on buyers and sellers came out on October 14, 2026, and it set new records. I talk about it in this week’s video, and the numbers matter for anyone in Murfreesboro and Rutherford County who plans to buy or sell.

What Does It Mean When Sellers Outnumber Buyers?

It means the number of people trying to sell a home is larger than the number of people looking to buy one. Redfin has a simple line for this. If sellers outnumber buyers by more than 10%, Redfin calls it a buyer’s market. In September 2026 the national gap was 62.6%, up from 56.9% in August.

That is not a small move. Redfin says it is the widest gap in its records since 2013, and it is the fourth month in a row that set a new record. Sellers were at about 1.5 million, the most since March 2020. Buyers fell to about 929,000, the lowest Redfin has ever counted.

How Big Is the Gap in the Nashville Area?

Bigger than almost anywhere in the country. Redfin found that sellers outnumbered buyers by 152.3% in the Nashville metro, which includes Rutherford County. Only Miami, at 158.9%, had a wider gap among the 50 large metros Redfin tracks. In all, 41 of those 50 metros are buyer’s markets.

Redfin, September 2026BuyersSellersSellers over buyers
United Statesabout 928,892about 1,510,78462.6%
Nashville metro7,16118,068152.3%

Here is a simple way to picture it. In the Nashville area there are about 2.5 sellers for every buyer. Across the whole country it is closer to 1.6 sellers for every buyer. That is why Nashville area buyers have so many homes to pick from.

The Gap Is Not Just About Sellers Redfin’s economist describes this market as born out of caution, not strength. More sellers are listing, but the bigger story is that fewer buyers are willing to jump in. The 30 year fixed mortgage rate was 7.4% this week, and many buyers are waiting on the sidelines.

What Is Happening in Murfreesboro and Rutherford County?

Our local numbers tell the same story. The Turner Victory Team tracks Rutherford County every week using live Realtracs MLS data and our Tru Insights™ platform. For the week ending October 17, 2026, Rutherford County had 1,730 homes for sale and 3.65 months of supply. Only 66 homes went under contract that week. That is the lowest week of 2026, and it is down from 116 in the same week last year.

The Turner Victory Team Market Health Score was 35. A score below 40 points to a buyer’s market. You can see the live numbers any time on our Rutherford County market data page, and we explain the bigger picture in our guide to the Murfreesboro buyers market.

What Does It Mean for Murfreesboro Sellers?

It means your home has more competition. Buyers can flip through a hundred homes online and pick only a few to tour. Your home has to pass that first online judgment, and then it has to pass a second judgment in person. We explain that in how buyers pick which homes to see in Murfreesboro.

In this kind of market, it is usually not a lack of eyes on the home. The MLS, the big portals and agent websites already show your home to nearly every active buyer. What decides the sale is how the home is presented and how it is priced. A few steps help:

  • Price the home for today’s market, not for the sale down the street from a few months ago.
  • Make sure the photos and details look great online.
  • Do the small updates and cleaning that make the home feel cared for. Our guide on how to prepare your home for showings is a good place to start.

Homes are still selling every day. The ones that win are priced right and look great.

What Does It Mean for Murfreesboro Buyers?

You have leverage. With so many homes to choose from, you can take your time, compare more homes and ask for more. Not every seller will make a deal, but some will do a lot to get their home sold. That could mean a lower price, help with closing costs or repairs.

The key is knowing which sellers are motivated and what to ask for. That is where a good agent helps. A buyer’s market gives you more power, but you still need a plan so you do not miss a good home or overpay for a weak one.

Should You Wait for the Market to Change?

I will be honest about this one: no one knows. Rates may stay near 7.4%, drop into the sixes or rise. If you have a job transfer or another reason to move, what happens to rates next year does not matter as much as what you do now. Markets change all the time, so the best plan is to use the information in front of you today. That is what we share every week.

If you want to talk through your own plans, there is no pressure. We will walk through your numbers, your timeline and your options, and you decide what is best.

Questions About Sellers Outnumbering Buyers in Murfreesboro

It means there are more people trying to sell a home than there are people ready to buy one. Redfin says sellers outnumbered buyers by 62.6% across the country in September 2026. When that gap grows, buyers get more choices and more room to negotiate, and sellers have to work harder to get a contract.
Redfin calls it a buyer’s market when sellers outnumber buyers by more than 10%. The national gap in September 2026 was 62.6%, far above that line. Redfin also found that 41 of the 50 large metro areas it tracks are buyer’s markets.
Redfin counted about 18,068 sellers and 7,161 buyers in the Nashville metro in September 2026. That is a gap of 152.3%, or about 2.5 sellers for every buyer. Only Miami had a wider gap among the 50 metros Redfin tracks.
The Turner Victory Team Market Health Score for Rutherford County was 35 for the week ending October 17, 2026. A score below 40 points to a buyer’s market. The county had 1,730 homes for sale and 3.65 months of supply that week.
Not always, and not for every home. A buyer’s market gives buyers more power in the deal. That can show up as a lower price, help with closing costs, or repairs. Homes that are priced right and look great online still get offers.
Redfin says active buyers hit the lowest count in its records, about 928,892 nationally. Redfin’s economist describes the market as born out of caution, not strength. The 30 year fixed mortgage rate was 7.4% this week, and many buyers are waiting on the sidelines.
No one knows where rates will go in six or nine months. If you need to move now, make your decision with the information you have today. If you do not have to move, talk it over with us first so you can compare your options.
Price the home for the market as it is today, not for the last sale on your street. Make sure the photos and details look great online, because that is where the first judgment happens. Then make sure the home feels clean, cared for and well kept when buyers walk in.
Take your time and compare more homes. You have more leverage than buyers have had in years, but not every seller will make a deal. Work with an agent who knows which sellers are motivated and can ask for the right things.
Only 66 homes went under contract for the week ending October 17, 2026. That is the lowest week of 2026 and down from 116 in the same week last year. Homes are still selling, but buyers are picking only the top homes on their list.

Thinking About Selling in This Market?

The Turner Victory Team will show you how buyers in your price range are likely to see your home and what that means for price and presentation.

Reach Out

See the Live Rutherford County Market Data

Weekly charts, price range breakdowns, months of supply, and the Turner Victory Team Market Health Score, updated every week. No signup required.

See the Live Charts
John Turner, Turner Victory Team
John Turner
Team Leader, Turner Victory Team

John Turner is the team leader of the Turner Victory Team at Onward Real Estate in Murfreesboro, Tennessee. John Turner has led the team since 2000. John Turner is the creator of Tru Insights™ and Tru Probability™, the proprietary tools the Turner Victory Team uses to analyze the Rutherford and Williamson County real estate markets. The Turner Victory Team has helped 4,502+ clients across 26+ years, and is ranked No. 12 in Tennessee by transaction sides and No. 14 by sales volume among large teams, RealTrends Verified 2026, based on 2025 sales data. Yahoo Finance cited John Turner by name as the on-the-ground market expert for Murfreesboro in May 2026.